Be it because you live in a country with a cold winter, where taking your gloves out to use your smartphone outdoors can be a painful experience, or simply due to personal preference, a lot of people expect more of their smartphones then a flat touchscreen without any other way to control the device. In the past this was no issue, since most Symbian and Windows CE devices came with touchscreens made for usage with a stylus and most of them were also controlable using directional keys. But in the latest generation of smartphones there has been a radical change towards touch-only devices. The first device to push this in the most radical way was the iPhone, which comes with only 1 navigation button: a home button.
Fortunately for Android fans, in the Android world things are not monopolized by a single manufacturer and there already hundreds and hundreds of Android smartphone models to choose from. But now the question remains: From this jungle of devices, how to find a good one with as much as possible of support for hardware navigational keys? The following sections will review the best Android devices which attend the group of users which enjoys having an alternative to the touch screen.
Samsung Galaxy 5 and Pro
See all 4 photos Samsung Galaxy 5Source: Self made
See all 4 photos Samsung Galaxy ProSource: Self made
Samsung Galaxy 5 and Galaxy Pro
Let's start with Galaxy 5, also know as Samsung i5500. This is a good phone for dpad fans on a strict budget which want a small telephone. It can be bought by as low as US$140+shipping in Ebay, or something like 100 euros. Truth be said, the device was launched in June 2010, which makes it a bit dated, but it has an update to Android 2.2, which is nowadays the bare minimum to run a lot of software. One should also note that to ensure a low price on a new device one needs to wait for some time after its launch. Samsung does not mutilate the Android default UI, so it one can navigate everything in the phone using the directional keys, except for one part: There is no way to unblock the phone with the keys. One needs to drag in the touch screen, which is a bit annoying, but then there is little to be done here. Clearly the Android developers do not live in a place which can reach -20C in winter or else they would consider that making it usable with gloves is a must have. Of course one can buy special gloves or adapt one's own for modern touch screens, but I feel this is just the wrong approach. The problem is in the operating system and should be solved there. We should not adapt ourselves to technology, technology should adapt itself better for us. Despite being a budget phone, it comes with GPS, Wifi, Bluetooth and all other basic goodies indispensable in a smartphone.
And beyond Galaxy 5 there is also it's newer and more powerful cousin: Samsung Galaxy Pro, also known as B7510. This device features a qwerty keyboard which will likely make a lot of people very happy and they haven't forgotten the navigation keys! Yep, it has the traditional 4 arrow keys from desktop keyboards. It is also rather cheap, being available in eBay for as low as US$170+shipping, which will certainly convince most people to pay the extra $40 for it's improved specs over the Galaxy 5. To compare: Galaxy 5 has 600 MHZ against 800 MHz of Pro, and Pro has a full qwerty keyboard, cames already with Android 2.2 and is upgradable for 2.3 which should get the more picky applications and is a much newer model, being released in April 2011, 10 months ago. The main reason for choosing Galaxy 5 instead of Pro would be getting a smaller phone. The Galaxy Pro is slightly bigger in width then an iPhone with a protecting case.
And while we are at it discussing Samsung phones, don't be mistaken by Galaxy S and Galaxy Mini. Many Samsung phones come with a very big central button which may initially look like a dpad, or a button which can be pressed on its borders to act as directions, but it is not! It is just a big home button with no navigation capabilities.
Xperia Pro
See all 4 photos Source: Self made
Sony Xperia Play, Pro and Mini Pro
While Samsung offers the traditinal bar format, Sony offers 3 very different slide phones for dpad fans. The first is Xperia Play, I couldn't avoid to mention, because it comes with a slide joystick which obviously contains a dpad, or maybe in this case I should say joypad, besides the other joystick buttons. I'd recommend this phone for people really dedicated to gaming. The second phone is Xperia Pro, a more conventional slider with a large screen and a full qwerty keyboard. This phone comes with a 1 GHz processor and was released in October 2011 with Android 2.3 with a planned upgrade to 4.0. Of course that like any other big keyboard slider it costs more too, and it can be found for around US$315+shipping in eBay.
The third phone is Xperia Mini Pro, part of the series of very small phones from Sony. Don't confuse it with Xperia X10 Mini Pro which is a similar, but older phone which comes also with a slider keyboard, but without directional keys. The tiny size and cheap price can be a blessing, but this phone has a serious defect: Sony decidede to mutilate the Android UI for its series of very small phones, and personally I hated their UI. It feels claustrophobic and many items don't show focus, which limits a lot the navigability. In general this can be a big problem and the Xperia Pro comes out as the best of the Sony key-friendly Android phones.
Motorola Milestone 2
See all 4 photos Source: Self made
Motorola Droid / Milestone 2, 3 and 4
And of course, when it comes to slide keyboard phones it is impossible not to mention the Motorola phone known as Motorola Droid in it's CDMA version and Motorola Milestone in it's GSM version. It is a pretty good slide keyboard phone, although a bit expensive and because it has 3 versions available with arrow keys there are plenty of options to choose, which will basically be the same phone, but older versions are slower and use an older Android, but for that are also much cheaper. The latest version hasn't yet been marketed as Milestone, so far being called simply Droid 4 and was shown recently in the World Mobile Congress.
HTC phones
Unfortunately I cannot recommend HTC phones for hardware key fans. And I say unfortunatelly because HTC phones are great value for the money. The fact is that the HTC Sense interface which HTC uses in substitution of the standard Android UI removed the hability to use the navigation keys to navigate through icons in the desktop, which severely limits the usability of the phone with hardware keys. Other then that HTC Sense is pretty ok, but this is a major problem for me while using my HTC Wildfire. Also note that the original Wildfire came with a trackball, which was pretty good, but then in newer phones HTC migrated to the horrible optical trackball is does not work well with gloves and when summed with HTC Sense is nearly completely useless. On recent phones they even removed the optical trackball completely, so HTC is out of my choice list.
Comparison of the mentioned devices
| Samsung I5500 Galaxy 5 | Samsung Galaxy Pro B7510 | Sony Ericsson Xperia pro | Sony Ericsson Xperia mini pro | Motorola Milestone 2 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Release | August 2010 | April 2011 | October 2011 | August 2011 | October 2010 |
| Android Version | 2.1 upgrade to 2.2 | 2.2 | 2.3 planned upgrade to 4.0 | 2.3 planned upgrade to 4.0 | 2.2 upgrade to 2.3 |
| Dimensions | 108 x 56 x 12.3 mm | 108.6 x 66.7 x 10.7 mm | 120 x 57 x 13.5 mm | 92 x 53 x 18 mm | 116.3 x 60.5 x 13.7 mm |
| Display | 240x320, 2.8'', 143 dpi | 320x240, 2.8'', 143 dpi | 480x854, 3.7'', 265 dpi | 320x480, 3'', 192 dpi | 480x854, 3.7'', 265 dpi |
| Camera | 2 MP | 3.15 MP | 8 MP | 5 MP | 5 MP |
| CPU | 600 MHz | 800 MHz ARMv6 | 1 GHz Scorpion + GPU Adreno 205 | 1 GHz Scorpion + GPU Adreno 205 | 1 GHz Cortex-A8 GPUPowerVR SGX530 |
| WiFi, Bluetooth, Video, 3G, GPS | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Form and Keyboard | Bar, only Virtual Keyboard | Bar, Qwerty | Slide out qwerty | Slide out qwerty | Slide out qwerty |
| Price (aproximate) | $130 or 100 | $160 or 120 | $315 or 240 | $140 or 100 | $250 or 190 |
Samsung Galaxy Pro
 | New Samsung Galaxy Rugby Pro Unlocked SGH-I547 8GB Black Android Smartphon Current Bid: $396.00 |
 | Samsung Galaxy Rugby Pro SGH-I547 - 8GB - Black (AT&T) Smartphone Current Bid: $158.50 |
Sony Xperia Pro
 | PDair Leather Case for Sony Ericsson Xperia Pro MK16i (Book Type With Clip) Current Bid: $19.99 |
 | Purple Mesh Net Cover Hard Case +Film for Sony Ericsson Xperia Pro MK16i QMCD132 Current Bid: $.75 |
0 comments:
Post a Comment